PennDOT gets tough on gas companies


Article Tools
Font size: [A] [A] [A]
Sign Up newsletter

Photo: N/A, License: N/A, Created: 0000:00:00 00:00:00

Review Photo/JAMES LOEWENSTEIN Chesapeake Energy Field Superintendent Brad Wittrock (in middle) says the company is planning to upgrade nine state routes in the county, beyond what is required by the state. At left is Rich Gulyas, education coordinator for the Bradford County Conservation District. At right is Brian Toseki of the state Department of Transportation.

Photo: N/A, License: N/A, Created: 0000:00:00 00:00:00

Review Photo/JAMES LOEWENSTEIN Mike Narcavage, representing Chesapeake Energy Corp., says the company has hired 16 contractors to repair roads damaged by its trucks in Bradford County.

TOWANDA - The state Department of Transportation is hiring three more inspectors for Bradford County to address the damage on state roads caused by heavy truck traffic and has warned gas drilling companies this week that they will need to deploy all resources necessary to keep state roads passable and safe or else they will have their road permits pulled, a state Department of Transportation official said at a meeting Wednesday in Towanda.

State Department of Transportation officials met Wednesday in Montoursville with representatives from gas drilling companies operating in the area and told them they will need to deploy whatever resources it takes to repair the state routes they are using in Bradford and other counties and keep them safe and passable, or they will have their permits to use the roads revoked, PennDOT Maintenance Services Manager Brian J. Toseki said at a meeting in Towanda of the Bradford County Gas Advisory Committee.

"If they need to have a road crew on every road every day (repairing the road), then that's what they'll have to do," Toseki said the Bradford County Gas Advisory Committee meeting.

The issue of road problems was the main topic of discussion at the meeting of the Gas Advisory Committee, which was attended by the three Bradford County commissioners, representatives from Sen. Gene Yaw's and Rep. Tina Pickett's offices, Chesapeake Energy Corp. officials, Toseki, and a several township supervisors.

Bradford County Commissioner Mark Smith opened the meeting, saying that there are "a lot of boiling infrastructure issues" with the roads in the county, such as people not getting mail delivered and the issue of "making sure emergency vehicles can travel on some of these roads."

To address the damage caused by heavy truck traffic on state routes in Bradford County, PennDOT has been posting weight limits on the roads and then requiring companies whose vehicles exceed the weight limit to post a bond in order to use the road. The bond is used to repair the road if the company damages the road.

Two years ago, there were 30 state routes in Bradford County that were posted with weight limits, Toseki said.

Today, there are more than 130 state routes in the county that are posted with weight limits, he said. A total of 320 miles of state routes in Bradford County now have weight limits posted on them, he said.

Delivery trucks, school buses, and trucks making fuel deliveries to local homes are exempt from the weight restrictions.

Toseki said it was after the gas industry began operating in the area that PennDOT began having significant problems with damage to posted roads in Bradford and Tioga counties.

The gas industry "kind of caused some of these issues" on the posted roads, he said.

PennDOT is hiring three more inspectors for Bradford County "who will do nothing but inspect posted and bonded roads" in Bradford County to make sure that the roads are repaired and are kept safe and passable, Toseki said.

To address increased costs of maintaining its post-and-bond program, including purchasing signs and administering the program, PennDOT will begin charging companies for inspections on posted roads, effective April 1, Toseki said.

Local residents who find problems on state routes that are caused by heavy truck traffic should report them by calling PennDOT at 1-800-FIX-ROAD, Toseki said.

To report problems caused by heavy truck traffic on township roads, residents should first try to contact their township supervisors, Toseki said.

If they are unsuccessful in reaching their township supervisors, they can call 1-800-FIX-ROAD, and PennDOT will relay the complaint to the appropriate township officials, he said.

Mike Narcavage, who works as a government specialist for Chesapeake Energy, said Chesapeake has hired 16 contractors to work on repairing roads in Bradford County. Those contractors have approximately 22 crews working in the county on road repairs for Chesapeake, he said.

"They are constantly fixing the roads" for Chesapeake, he said.

"We've got every piece of equipment and every contractor we can find" repairing the roads, he said, adding that the contractors have to meet Chesapeake's standards.

However, county commissioner Smith said after the meeting that he has been told there are not enough contractors available to do the work and not enough local quarries to supply the material to repair the roads.

"I've been informed that they (gas drilling companies) are struggling to find contractors ... at this point," he said.

Brad Wittrock, a field superintendent for Chesapeake, said he believed problems with the roads will improve in the coming weeks.

"I think we've probably seen the worst of it," he said.

McLinko agreed that the roads will improve in the coming weeks because normally the weather becomes dryer. However, he said the dryer weather will cause a dust problem on the roads used by the trucks.

Upgrades

Narcavage also said that Chesapeake met with PennDOT officials earlier this week to discuss its plan to upgrade nine state routes in Bradford County, beyond what is required by the state.

Under PennDOT's post-and-bond regulations, Chesapeake is only required to bring the nine state routes back to the condition they were in before the company started using them, said Brad Wittrock, a field superintendent for Chesapeake.

But Wittrock said improvements that Chesapeake are proposing would go beyond what the state requires.

"What we proposing are upgrades to the roads," Wittrock said.

He said that PennDOT was "happy" with Chesapeake's plans for the upgrades.

Chesapeake will provide PennDOT with engineering and design work as soon as possible for the upgrades, which will affect 30 miles of road, he said.

The upgrades will begin as soon as PennDOT can review and approve the engineering and design work, he said.

Bradford County Commissioner Doug McLinko said he has arranged for Sen. Yaw and state representatives Pickett and Matt Baker to tour damaged roads in Bradford County and speak to township supervisors about the road problems.

He said it is important for them to see the problems first-hand.

McLinko also said he has talked to supervisors from Tuscarora, Towanda and Terry townships who are happy with the road maintenance agreements they have with gas drilling companies and the repair work that has been arranged by gas drilling companies for those roads.

Toseki also said he expected that local plants that make hot-mix asphalt, which is used to pave roads, to open earlier this year, due to the large demand for the material for local road repairs.

"I believe they will open in early April this year," which is several weeks earlier than normal, Toseki said.

James Loewenstein can be reached at (570) 265-1633; or e-mail: jloewenstein@thedailyreview.com.







Type in the characters you see in the picture below. If you have trouble reading the characters in the picture, click it to see a new one.



21 posted comments

The roads suffered more frost damage this winter. The winter wasn't as cold, but the biggest factor in depth of frost is snow cover. If there's less snow, less insulation, then the frost goes deeper. When the frost along the roadsides goes deeper, the frost under the road goes deeper. The Berwick Turnpike, between Spring Lake and Burlington, goes totally to pieces and is repaved about every three years. It is worse this year than it has been in the forty years I have been using it to go from Monroeton to Elmira. They are doing major work on it right now, probably more extensive than the patch and pray covering that has been done in the past. Maybe the end result will last longer, but until a decent base is put under the road, little will change.
patience 03/20/10 6:05
Realist- WHAT?
All you need to do is drive on a road that the frost thawing and then drive on a road that has been used by the gas company.
Being a Realist is realizing the truth, the gas companies are doing as they please at the communities expense.
I have seen bad roads and this year is the worst that I have ever seen.
Lifelong Resident 03/20/10 9:32
P.s. to Kathy: Regarding the methane gas/well issue - I haven't seen enough research to make an informed decision but I do believe it's related.
We have our own issues regarding water - our well collapsed when the drilling began near our home and we're currently working with the gas company to resolve the issue. We've found the gas company to be extremely helpful.
Realist 03/19/10 10:44
Kathy, if you re-read my original comment, you will see in the first sentence that I'm not giving gas companies a full pardon. I'm just saying they are not the SOLE blame for our road conditions.
Realist 03/19/10 10:20
Thank you too funny, I rest my case! The grammar in this post is probably why it wasn't published in the letter to the editor column. If you're going to make a complaint at least try to sound intelligent about it!
Educated 03/19/10 8:41
One of the residents present at the meeting also contributed a very sensible solution which she said is used in the western part of the state, according to some gas workers in our area now. They stop traveling the roads during spring thaw. A short delay, and you avoid lots of problems. No sense ripping up roads when a short delay will keep you from having to fix them all summer long. Let's have some people with backbone enough to call a short break in the drilling action.
Common sense 03/19/10 4:54
Yes, for the local economy, we can live with some mangled roads. But what they're doing to roads in the Towanda, Terry Twp., and Dushore areas is simple not acceptable. There are busy, country routes, that are used a by dozens of folks, not associated with the drilling at all. We live on these roads, and can't get to our homes. I had to walk about a mile, after parking my truck in a farm field.. Because when I left home that morning, my road was just the same as it was ten years ago. About eleven hours later, it was gone. Literally, gone, they had it down to mud, a foot or two below the road surface. What if my house caught fire? or what if someone needs an ambulance, and they can't get in? Who pays for that? We need to sue the land owners where the wells are being built. It's a public safety threat. They need to do more than fill roads in with 6" round rocks. Who is going to replace my vehicle? It will wear out 2 years before it normally would have.
Bill - Dushore 03/19/10 1:00
pleas send south creek some money or new equipment the 2 men could realy use it .they will never be able to fix them with what we have even some neighbors pitched in last year to help out with the water problem we had on gee rd thanks don sherwood ,gary brennan and especially mike and debbi melchionne for all your help
bc tax payer 03/18/10 11:33
I live in Sullivan County, and we are starting to see the same kind of problems - only our problem is the local contractors. The heavy dump trucks are destroying the roads. And there are no plans to fix them as of this time. I keep hearing that we had a "cold" winter, but I disagree, we had a "wet" fall and winter, but not as cold as it usually gets around here. More rain, less snow.
Elkland Township Resident 03/18/10 9:24
Educated, what you wrote shows that apparently you're still in school and i missed the part where spring lake stated he was a writer. Educated, what part of his comment don't you understand? I do see where there's puncuations a few s's missing and where he's just being smart. Spring lake, if some don't get this they don't need to. They're not driving on these seconddary roads. I believe you're state route 2015 is apparently the same condition as my route. 'Cause i'm seeing the same things going on. And nobody's going to tell me that these roads would still be in the same condition if all these multiple trucks weren't traveling on them 24/7. Spring lake, next time just take your time and you would not be confusing some, although i'm sure there's alot out there that do know.
Canton 03/18/10 5:25
Educated, Well maybe you arn't as bright as you think you are. If you can't figure out what they are saying then just ignore them no need for you to be obnoxious.
Pete 03/18/10 4:30
Just an FYI to those who think the gas isn't the main cuase of the road damage. One loaded tractor trailer is equal to 10,000 passenger cars driving over the same road. With that being said, I do believe the gas companies will help fix the roads.
Ken T. 03/18/10 4:18
wow spring lake...are you sure one of those ROCKS didn't miss your vehicle and hit you square in the head? between the penguins and lollipops i wonder if maybe you are hallucinating.
too funny 03/18/10 3:56
Realist I have also lived here for about 2 decades and NEVER before has the Burlington Turnpike been completely impassable from Mt. Lake to Route 6. It looks like a minefield with craters so big my entire car went down inside of them and had to crawl back out! Going around it isn't a choice because it covers across the entire road. This is NOT frost damage. Stop making excuses for the gas company that it's not their fault the roads are heaving up...or do you also believe that the people getting methane in their wells isn't because of the gas company either? Maybe the methane has been waiting to make it's appearance until it could blame it on somebody else huh??!!
Kathy Brenner 03/18/10 2:33
While there is increased traffic with the influx of gas, these companies aren't the sole blame. I've lived in this region since 1972 and road conditions in March and April have historically been bad because of the thaw.
Our state's leaders need to take some of the blame for not using taxdollars earmarked for repairs. Those resources seem to get lost amid special interest projects.
It all boils down to greed.
Realist 03/18/10 12:31
They need to keep reminding people that this is not all done by trucks. We had a wetter than normal fall and a colder winter than usually. All of this let the frost go deeper and make for more problems on our roads. I have been on a lot of road where there is no big truck traffic and they are not much better As a Tax payer i am glad for what the gas companys are doing to fix the roads, because a lot of this would be for us to fix from the thaw that they are now fixing. We all just need to slow down take our time and enjoy life, not try to rush through it. We have all damage our cars before gas life, and no one ever paid for it. We called pen dot, they got to it some time over the next several month. Never has there been the number of contractors working on our roads this early. Lets remember maybe they will be taken care of better than ever at no cost to the tax payers thanks to the gas companies.
cc 03/18/10 12:03
Spring Lake, Maybe you should go back to schoo. Most of your rant doesn't make sense!
Educated 03/18/10 11:56
I was trying to get this in yesterday’s letters to the editor. Must have sent it the wrong way or to the wrong place not sure.O well. And now I do see in today's some is being addressed……we hope…………….. Has all even realized that this past winter was the coldest for the longest we have had in a long time the frost got deeper than usual. And then were adding 30 big trucks every 2 hours on these secondary roads as it starts to thou out. Common cents should tell you what was going to happen. But please some of these companies please train your drivers! These roads would not be as bad if the drivers would flow left and right from one side to the other side running over them spongy high spot it’s not going to tip you over as yawl travel throw. Each time they come through. As of now they look like “THE MARCH OF THE PENGUINS” Same path each time. Not just that I see the trucks doing this and I do. The roads show the trench in it from them doing that some spot some spot. For as slow as they go it’s not going to hart them or anything.
Now got some more for all who cares. What’s up with the ROCK’s the size of softballs and bigger is everybody driving trucks with lift kit’s in them?
Come on it is going to be a pain in the butt to get compensated or help with the damages this is causing to peoples car and yes the SUV too. I can just imagine hello Mr Gas Company or PENNDOT or Township can you help me with my costs and damages? They will more than likely look at me as if I was losing my mind.
As of now I got one new tire with a broken belt. My oil pan is crushed in. A side marker light smashed out. I saw that one coming rock the size of a baseball big truck front tire caught the edge of it and snapped it right at me and smash. All on state route 2015
I’m not exaggerating those ROCKS are to dam big for what they’re using them for. I did see one of the 5 or 6 companies doing something I thought was the right way. They were digging down getting out the mushy mud then added those size rocks and YES then some SUB BASE some finer stuff. You look at that now it looks good and feels good as you go over it.
This was three or four weeks ago and still.
Just saying come on companies. If you’re not sure find out what right. And do it right the first time. And another thing where are the flaggers?
You know a person with a big lollipop that reads stop or slow and Signs warning people hay there something going on up ahead here. There should be ones out there. If I remember right when I worked road construction years ago it was the law there will be sign out and trained flaggers. O one more thing is there suppose to be a state inspector you know some qualified and certified to make sure all is done by STATE specs. Ok I’m done venting.
love spring lake not the roads 03/18/10 9:30
Thanks to The Review for this reporting. But it is not just Chesapeake. Here in Wells Township it is Talisman Energy that is destroying our roads. The heavy truck traffic is incessant, at all hours of the night and day, seven days a week. I hope some of these new resources are also deployed out our way. We are part of Bradford County, too.
Barbara Hunsinger 03/18/10 8:59
If you would like a TRUE opinion of what the road comditions are like, you need to talk to the residents who live there rather than the commissioners and supervisors who Chesapeake has bought and paid for to speak on their behalf.
Big Bad Brad 03/18/10 6:53