Boldness must arise locally to save roads


Article Tools
Font size: [A] [A] [A]
Sign Up newsletter

It's nearly spring and the secondary roads here are in poor shape. Some of the main roads, as well. It's an annual occurrence. But, this year there is a dramatic difference.

More roads are in far worse shape than perhaps ever before, in large part because of the battering from heavy trucks, many of which are in the area tending to the burgeoning natural gas industry.

Our countywide report Friday documented some of the worst locations. Efforts are underway to cope. But they are falling far short. Existing resources, public and private, are overwhelmed.

Where is the leadership? Where is our lightning rod? Entangled in politics?

Individual road masters, township supervisors and residents are left to howl in the wind. There is no coordination. Who will step up with thoughtful, reasoned insight?

Anybody? Anybody?

At the moment, it's mild-mannered Ed Grant, a man who stepped out of nowhere other than a long history of thoughtful local government participation. He calls for a coordinating coalition, a clearinghouse to get things prioritized and moving. It's the best we've heard yet!

But, the best that could be offered in return at Thursday's county commission meeting was to suggest to Mr. Grant, a Burlington town supervisor who appeared before the county's top elected political leaders to seek relief, that he attend a county committee meeting on natural gas next week. A committee meeting! What a tattered and frayed bureaucratic hand-me-down to cope with such a sizzling crisis!

Meanwhile, the county crumbles. Safety is imperiled. Lifestyles are jeopardized.

Inconvenience is an issue for motorists, of course. But far more important is safety for drivers. Safety for cars, safety for small trucks, safety for school buses carting children, and safety for big trucks, farm equipment and other vehicles.

Residents were warned about such looming hardships two years ago by county commissioners who saw early on some of the pros and cons of the natural gas boom resulting from exploitation of the Marcellus Shale play under Bradford County.

But, no one foresaw such a rapid expansion of prospecting and drilling - and infrastructure deterioration. Oversight, direction, regulation, control all lagged while the county was being transformed for better or for worse. Virtually all the mineral rights in Bradford County have been leased to gas companies, according to the Shirley Rockefeller, county register and recorder. Permits for 430 wells were issued by the state Department of Environmental Protection in 2009 for Bradford County alone, and 113 new wells were drilled. The rapid pace continues this year with 29 more drilling permits issued in January, second in the state only to Tioga County.

Plans for pipelines to transport the gas to markets are in the works. PennDOT, which only last week warned of a regional problem, says more than 60 roads in the county have been posted with weight restrictions. It is hard-pressed to keep up.

Behemoths lumber down the highways, some oversized, some overweight and, in too many cases, going too fast. They include 5,500 gallon and larger water tankers, flat beds to haul equipment, and dump trucks to haul material, all of which clog the roads, and grind the pavement. Crashes are more and more common. State police are levying unheard of fines for illegal loads running in the tens of thousands of dollars.

The roads, especially the secondary and tertiary roads are being pounded and pulverized into pot holes, gullies and broken shoulders. Driving is a hazard. Residents are growing impatient, even angry. Township supervisors and other municipal officials are at wits end.

It's a crisis.

Worse, there is no plan for orderly transition to the new economy, the new Bradford County. Where are the commissioners, where are the state representatives (Pickett, Baker, Yaw), where is the governor, where is the Northern Tier Regional Planning Commission. Where is …. ? All too wrapped up in their own bureaucratic worlds to step into the real worlds and deal with one of the most important, transformational phenomena to face the region ever?

There appears to be no knowledgeable, effective coordinated effort to evaluate and make recommendations for improvement in any logical way. No prioritizing of problems, no prioritizing of resources. In short, no leadership. It's a no-brainer. But, it took Mr. Grant to give it some life. Let's not let his idea die.

It's a chance for the county to shine. To rise to the occasion, to seize the reins and set something meaningful in action. The county commissioners have a bully pulpit. Abandon partisan politics. Unite for the greater good. Publicly snarl like a pit bull at the state laggards who choke off the money and stifle creative thinking. Be visible. Adopt a crash program. Meet daily and speak out until something is figured out and the powers that be agree to help. An election looms. Be courageous. Be behind your constituents. Be right.

There is money tucked away in government coffers. Be creative. Who will have the courage, and astuteness to stand up and go after it? Insist on emergency legislation if necessary? Pennsylvania, with the worst roads and bridges in the country, assesses a tax of 38.1 cents per gallon on diesel fuel, the highest state rate, and 32.3 cents per gallon on gasoline. The federal government adds 18.4 cents per gallon of gasoline and 24.4 cents per gallon for diesel fuel. The state taxes most recently were raised in 2006. Get some of that money. Figure out how.

The as-yet unauthorized severance tax aside for now, there are WAMS, and there is the legislative slush fund. Insist that money be pried loose to provide immediate help to prime the pump for infrastructure, including roads, relief.

It must be done now.

It can no longer be business as usual. Conditions will only worsen.







Type in the characters you see in the picture below. If you have trouble reading the characters in the picture, click it to see a new one.



26 posted comments

i have seen these gas trucks filling up thier diesel tanks with off road fuel so they do not have to pay the fuel tax i thought this was illegal the dot need to watch thes truckers at the pumps that sell off road diesel this is a big fine if they get cought the off road fuel can easily be detected by the color wher is the department of transportation to inspect the truckers williams sells more off road diesel then any other in this area check it out
joeybagofdonuts 03/18/10 11:53
Sugert: We certainly allow other firms in the public sector to use public roads to further their business aims. However that does not give them, or any other business, carte blanche to use them to the point where they are a detriment to the rest of the public. That is why there are regulations to regulate and address the use and repair of roads,

We are not only talking about weight, we are also talking about volume and frequency also. It isn't just one or two times occasionally by commercial vehicles or farm equipment, its multiple times by multiple heavy load vehicles consistently for an extended, ongoing period of time. As we have seen, even in the best of times these roads require constant work to maintain any semblance of drivability.

This is why we require heavy vehicles to post bonds and pay permit fees. And yet as we have seen, these companies have allowed (if not encouraged) heavy load vehicles to operate unpermitted. That is not exactly a good neighbor policy. They are addressing the issue now because they realize it is in their best interest to do so.

I leave you with this question: If they do not help pay, who does? I think you already know the answer to that one.

ThomasPaine 03/18/10 2:08
TP, they are public roads. The gas companies are part of the public. What about the heavy mild trucks that drive on them? Should we make the farmers pay for the damage they do as well. What about other heavy loads?

By the way, I think Hector is right too. Especially about liberal programs haunting us into eternity.

Sugert 03/17/10 4:11
Sugert: Yep, we do have problems with secondary roads in the spring. But it doesn't take genius to figure out if you have heavily loaded vehicles running over them continuously under such conditons the roads will break up sooner and the damage will be worse. Simple fact. And those vehicles belong to the gas companies or their contractors. Simple fact. It is also right for them to assist in the repair for the roads their vehicles have accelerated the damage to.

Even the gas companies realize this. I give them the benefit of a doubt as to not expecting the roads to break down so soon and so badly. Hector is right, PA has a national reputation for bad roads. Local officials and roadmasters do what they can with limited funding but it is going to take significant funding on the state level for the roads to improve

ThomasPaine 03/16/10 10:34
It is an issue right now for all first responder agencies. The police departments are busy. The fire department calls are up just to the "disabled tractor trailers" alone. Add is the tragedies that have occurred in this county so far, and the fire department resources will go quickly. Imagine what the average driver pays for gas a week. Then think about the fire/ambulance apparatus that are on scene for hours. The roads are in such poor condition a decision has to be made as to what apparatus can travel on what roads. They travel to the ends of their districts, have to wait for the scene to be cleared, and that doesn't even include the countless manhours lost when these volunteers leave their jobs. So everyone suffers in one way or another.
Another concerned one 03/15/10 11:19
Back in the 1950s a liberal democrat by the name of Leader was elected Governor on one of his main planks of "getting the farmer out of the mud," by promising to pave many of the secondary roads which were then dirt. He did it by making "pie crust" roads. They just put a thin layer of payment over the dirt without establish a good foundation. Since then most all that has happened is additional layers of payment have been put down. Still no foundation. Another example of how popular liberal programs continue to haunt us into eternity.
Hector 03/15/10 6:53
Come on folks get real. The secondary roads in Bradford County break up virtually every Spring. This one's no different. This is nothing more than an effort to take advantage of the gas companies by asking them to pay for a common Spring ocurrance.
Sugert 03/15/10 6:45
Rep. Baker's plan which is to talk to PennDOT as reported in this paper in a separate article is not very bold. I agree that a bold plan is needed. Bold may be viewed as radical by some, but whatever you call it, a more aggressive plan is needed. The only thing I would disagree with in this editorial is the part about seeking government money to fix the roads. The gas companies promised to keep the roads in shape, let's hold them to using private money from their own pockets in resolving the road issues. Great editorial.
Frequent reader 03/15/10 1:23
Lets not forget about emergency response, folks. It's an issue NOW, not just later... yet nothing will be done until one of the public officials, or family, is harmed because an ambulance or fire apparatus got stuck or disabled on one of the roads destroyed by the gas companies. Will your neighbor's gas lease be worth it then?
The gas workers and locals who have a gas lease frequently spout off the excuse "well it isn't their fault, those roads werent made for big truck traffic". EXACTLY!! Those roads werent made for this, so the gas companies should have prepared the roads BEFORE they started... but that wouldnt have been cost effective, would it. Taking a grader to the road and throwing a load of dirt overtop is not a fix. I suspect we won't see a real fix for years... why repair a road destroyed by one gas well when you plan on putting another well right down the road? If someone dies as a result of those roads, they can't be held accountable, so they have no motivation to keep the public safe.
It's all about money, folks. These problems were predicted over a year ago, but the people receiving money fought back, claiming it was all propaganda. Now the problems are here, and the people receiving money are still fighting back, diminishing the seriousness of these issues. What's next? When the industry turns this area into a baron cesspool, everyone who got gas money, from the citizens to our corrupt politicians, will move away from the area while still collecting their gas check. The rest of us will have to stay here and deal with it without any compensation whatsoever... oh, except of course for that "trickle down" money that was "injected" into the local economy. Right. Ask anyone who isn't a restaurant owner, bar owner, hotel owner, or minimart/fuel depot owner about the "trickle down" money, and see what kind of reply you get. Oh, right... it will take "a while" for it to work it's way through the economy. Eh, no.
Off my soapbox.
Paul 03/15/10 12:52
I expect them to have enough common sense to stop running the roads until they harden up. Roads that aren't destroyed don't need to be fixed. So the bottom line us, don't build pads, drill or frac during spring thaw. Our loggers know how to manage their business around spring thaw, I expect that much courtesy from our gas drillers.
Spring Thaw means vacation time for drillers 03/15/10 12:51
Everybody knew in advance that the roads would take a beating, so ignorance is definitely not to blame. Quite simply, nobody in Harrisburg or Texas cares about the yokels in the Northern Tier. On the balance sheet, a busload of Troy elementary students is not worth one good gas well. Just get the Marcellus table scraps while you can and be grateful that you're not living in Centralia.
Ben 03/15/10 10:36
It is two weeks into march. the ground is still thawing. What do you expect them to do right now? Give them a chance. One person commented Where are all the jobs? Look on-line and in the classifieds, I see job opportunities in there. Sorry if you wanted a job where you could sit at home all day but thats not how it works. Get real.
Relax a bit 03/15/10 9:42
Robert, thank you for your optimistic comments. It is a pleasure to read some of your many open-ended questions with no suggestions offered. I will try to respond to some of your statements with a few observations of my own.
- The gas companies answer the phone...I have called several times and they quickly responded.
- Yes, we were warned from the beginning...any new venture comes with risks and rewards.
- Anyone with half a brain read their gas leases and obtained legal help to modify the lease with environmental protections.
- It would not be practical to use the gas that "you are right on top of", since the cost of running a high-pressure pipe to your house, depressurizing and cleaning the gas, etc. would be cost prohibitive. The better gas lease contracts were written with the gas company providing monetary compensation for heating your home. Also, properly written gas contracts make sure the landowner gets his/her fair share (royalties).
- I would not call the millions of dollars in gas lease payments to Bradford County landowners a "few token dollars". Also, the motels, restaurants, etc. are packed with gas workers. Anyone with a bit of entrepreneurial spirit could be starting a business (laundry, delivery service, etc.) to take advantage of the gas boom.
- In regards to our pristine area and the roads...unfortunately, our infrastructure in Bradford County is terrible. The roads are paved over cow paths, internet and cell phone service is limited, etc. I don't think the gas companies knew what they were getting into, but hopefully they will work with our elected officials to improve things.
- Sorry, sometimes progress comes with a price. We all have to work together to make sure the gas companies are held responsible for their activities.
Curmudgeon 03/15/10 9:28
Thank you Robert for your excellent post. We see what you see and are holding out from signing also. Keep spreading the word. It may seem too late to most, but it is not. There are many battles ahead with pipelines, impoundments, sludge ponds, compressor stations, fresh and recycled wastewater lines, and such.
Not hoodwinked in BC 03/15/10 8:33
The sad part about all of this is that Burlington Township has a good posting and bonding ordinance and a great excess maintenance agreement, but certain gas companies are bad-mouthing them to the other townships. The purpose of this is to manipulate the other townships to lay off posting and bonding and sign onto a boilerplate road maintenance agreement with the gas companies instead. The boilerplate road maintenance agreement gives the gas companies more freedom to do whatever they please. There is no financial security backing these agreements, so the townships are at their mercy. The tactics used to encourage the townships to sign on are slippery at best but unfortunately some innocent, well-meaning leaders can't see through the tricks and deceits. Although posting and bonding isn't a magical solution to the problem of the roads, right now, it is the best process available to the townships. The townships can close the roads, but I don't think many township leaders can stand up to the pressure from gas companies who will start claiming that the townships are holding up the wells and keeping their residents from getting their royalties. The gas companies have already demonstrated that they are willing to fire up residents and tell them to attend township meetings and well-intentioned leaders without strong constitutions or a clear understanding of what they are signing buckle under the pressure from misguided constituents and gas company pressure. People who want to protect their roads should contact their supervisors and insist that they post and bond their roads.
See through the deceit 03/15/10 8:22
Thanks to the Daily Review and Ed Grant for keeping this issue in the forefront. Relative to specific roads, I don't know why the state has opened Clapper Road back up, since the water and construction trucks are just tearing it back up. When is the gas company going to return it back to original condition? When they leave the state 50 years from now? Will we remember that we once had paved roads by then? If you think things are bad this year, just wait until next year. We will have three times as many wells and most of them will be undergoing fracking. So many more roads will be destroyed. The commissioners did not adequately inform the general populace about the expected impacts of gas drilling up front. Last year Asylum Township had road issues resulting from drilling, so it shouldn't be a surprise this year when the same effects are experienced everywhere. And don't forget Herrick Twp. with their road issues from their first well. Everyone acted like Southwestern was some kind of second class drilling outfit, but even the self-proclaimed #1 premiere drilling company of choice leaves the roads a mess.
Bad roads the new norm 03/15/10 8:16
Where I work, there are some of us that are trying to find another route to get to work to avoid the sometimes slippery mud slicked road RT. 6 has become with dust clouds rising on occasion so that we can barely see and water trucks barreling at us or behind us. The problem is, this puts us on the secondary roads and will take us much longer and these roads are in very poor condition. We just want to ge to work safely. For those of us who have driven RT 6 for years, it is nothing like we have ever seen before, and the crumbling secondary roads can not be compared to usual road conditions after a spring thaw. What has happened to our county ?
area worker 03/15/10 7:07
The work goes on. The roads will be fixed when the conditions are right and they will be remade at the gas companies' expense better than we would have ever done so with our tax revenues. In the meantime, it sure will be a pain in the backside. This editorial strikes me like all-of-a-sudden this is an issue for author . . . where have you been? The facts are that there are a number of rebuilt roads holding up nicely and I live on one.
Chill Pill 03/15/10 6:50
Well people the real truth is you seen a way to make a fast buck.
They promised to fix everything then you can't get them to answer the phone.
Fines are just a part of their business and a tax write off.
lawyers are not cheap and they have them on their payroll.
You were all warned from the beginning that this was going to happen just look at Mildred after the coal mining just slag left and the companies are gone not the government is doing the cleanup with your tax dollars.
you should have really read those contracts before you allowed this to happen, when the land and water is ruined they will be gone, just like the forever burning coal mines.
I would like to know being that you are right on top of the gas are you going to get it for free?
Are you going to get it at a reduced rate?
Are you going to get any of it?
Did they actually mine under your land and not tell you?
That is why I refused to sign with them.
There is nothing there for our people just a few token dollars.
Do you really think they are going to tell you how much gas they got from your land? Then give you your fair share.
Our local lawyers have never dealt against companies this big they will use there lawyers on their payroll while you have to shell out big bucks for yours and probably have to go to a district court for court hearings.
Too bad that area so pristine is on it's way to total ruination.
The money you will have gotten will be as the money Judas got to hand over Christ.
Enjoy your home while you can, you may be stuck there if the roads go back to the conditions of the time of the Pioneers.
Maybe you can dump your cars and buy Hummers with your new found money
Robert 03/14/10 6:31
Bradford County is learning to its horror the misery of being a sacrificial lamb. All the promises, the trips to Texas, all of it was a sham. The real agenda is massive extraction of our wealth, by and through any and all means necessary, from Bradford County natives. And especially sadly, in so many instances, this agenda is being advanced with the knowledge and cooperation of those very same people, and their leaders. Yes, Daily Review, this IS an excellent and insightful editorial. But nobody amongst the powers that be cares or is listening. And nobody will. All too many of them are themselves on the gravy train. And they put self interest far, far ahead of the public's interest. My best suggestion: Buy a 4WD jeep . . . or move.
Betty Thomas 03/14/10 1:47