mobile site Go to The Daily Review mobile

Letter to the Editor


Font size: [A] [A] [A]

Storm water management

EDITOR: It is important to understand that storm water is simply water from rain or melting snow that does not soak into the ground but runs off into waterways.

Ridgebury Township and the Bentley Creek stream is a good illustration of what can happen when we fail to address storm water run off. A hundred years or so ago the Bentley Creek stream was a placid stream that ran year round from pool to pool under a shaded canopy. Suckers used to come up from the Chemung River to spawn in the Spring of the year. That is no longer possible.

So what has happened? Early on the rains fell on field and forest, soaked in, and eventually the water made its way to the main stream over a period of days. This allowed the stream to maintain a more even flow. Then people came in and built homes, barns, driveways and other similar things that covered the ground where the rain used to soak in. Thus, we eventually ended up with the equivalent of three or four Wal-Mart parking lots with no defined catch basins. The stepped-up run off from rooftops and driveways runs straight into roadways and tributaries of Bentley Creek.

All of this stepped-up run off caused the main stream and many of its tributaries to expand their banks to accommodate a larger flow of water during rain events. Interpretation: Roads washed out, fields (topsoil) washed away at a loss to the township and the downstream landowners. What is left is wider streams, no cooling tree canopy, a lot of larger rocks and gravel domes and unstable banks just waiting to wash out with the next major rain event. Now we have high flows after a rain event and then dry streambeds for lack of enough of the slower yielding water coming in through springs.

So do we continue to let people build and destroy our roads and do damage to their downstream neighbors or do we take steps to make sure we realize our past mistakes with regards to storm water. Our county commissioners and township supervisors take an oath to protect the health and safety of their constituents. I submit that they have stuck their heads in the sand and are not carrying out their responsibilities in refusing to address storm water run off.

It is interesting to note that in our neighboring Chemung County that the earth movers are required to attend training in storm water run off at the county level and receive a card to certify that they have taken the training. Building permits in that county have to include how the builder is going to deal with storm water run off and they have to have a card-carrying excavator to do the work.

People need to realize that keeping their storm water on their land is often beneficial in keeping their water table healthy enough that their wells will have water during droughts. They need to realize that dealing with their run off in a responsible manner does not have to be costly. Often just directing said water into a low cost French Drain could do the trick. Just realizing that not dealing with this run off is not being a good neighbor to those down stream of them should be reason enough to change the way they treat their run off.

I trust this letter clarifies the need for responsible treatment of storm water run off. If we continue to ignore this issue we will repeat the mistakes of the past and in the case of Bentley Creek destroy millions of dollars of stream protection that has been put in place.

County wide we stand to destroy valuable property and cause millions of dollars in damage.

Ken Cooke

Gillett







Type in the characters you see in the picture below. If you have trouble reading the characters in the picture, click it to see a new one.



6 posted comments

underwater - thanks for the reply (and apologies for taking so long to acknowledge your reply).

I would hope that Monroe Borough officials would be sending this up the chain of government, probably to Tina Pickett for her referral to the proper state agency.

BC Native 02/02/10 10:39
The grade where the railroad bridge used to be in Monroeton is no problem at low water levels. As the water level approaches flood stage it begins to pile up against the embankment and take the path of least resistance, right down through the middle of town. In one of our floods many years ago a long-time boro resident with demolition experience was headed down the railroad grade with a satchel of dynamite to resolve the problem. The Army corps of engineers stopped him. If twenty or thirty feet of this railroad abutment were removed, or better yet pushed upstream to form a funnel, the water could seek nature's original channel. Such action would also afford us the opportunity to see if Mr. Gorman's concrete structures at the end of the 220 bridge would protect his house. Before he died, I told him that if the creek was prevented from flowing down through the center of town during floods, that his concrete structures would be ineffective, and his house would be gone. He agreed.
underwater 01/29/10 1:48
underwater - what obstruction do you refer to - the railroad grade to New Albany or something else?
BC Native 01/29/10 9:54
Every community should look at these issues. Whether their dikes need improvement, or such obstacles need to be removed. Remember in the 70's when the Army Corp of Engineers did not think Athens need to improve the flood walls. The people of Athens took it upon themselves to improve the flood walls. Flood level for Athens is 26 feet. That was forward thinking. It is what we need to prevent another devastating, region wide flood. The river and streams are easily overwhelmed, and overflow their banks. It can be prevented and corrected. Everyone just needs to come together, and work on a plan..then work that plan.
Engineer needed 01/28/10 9:17
In the storm earlier this week, Monroeton came close again to a downtown flood. It happens with a snowpack on Barclay Mt., fast melting in a rain storm. A couple hours work with a bulldozer could remove a manmade obstruction that is no longer of any purpose and keep the creek in its original channel. Do you think the borough council will do this? Probably one of the gas companies would donate machine and an operator. it honestly wouldn't take two hours, and would have prevented five floods in my lifetime. Utterly stupid!
underwater 01/28/10 3:45
Mr. Cooke is correct. If it were still the 1800's, this would not be a problem. Look at the flooding last week. With man coming in and upsetting the balance of nature, we must do our utmost to restore what is lost. Whose land and property do you want to destroy, just to fight this issue. Ridgebury this is not the 1800's, it is the 21st century, and you should respect those who take the time and effort to study these issues.
It makes your community sound like back-country hillbillies, when you deny what is clearly the truth.
It is important that the members of the community, who are aware of these facts, to come forward and support your elected officials.
Don't let a few loud, rude, rowdy individuals control your town.
Stand up to these bullies, and they will stand down.
Former Ridgebury Res 01/28/10 12:16

POLL

Which one of the following best describes you?

Show results

Volunteer Pay

Support your community newspaper by making a voluntary donation to assist our Internet efforts.

Coupons

Now on thedailyreview.com, print coupons and SAVE!

m.thedailyreview.com

Now you can access thedailyreview.com on your favorite mobile device.
Latest on thedailyreview.com

Saint Pattys

Click to Win

King Features

Get your daily dose of Comics, Horoscopes and Puzzles from thedailyreview.com

NIE MAJOR SPONSOR

Thanks to Chesapeake Energy for helping to develop our future readers, writers and thinkers by providing newspapers for area classrooms through The Review's Newspaper in Education Program.

Thank you

to our Associate Sponsors for supporting the NIE program.

USA Weekend

USA Weekend Weekly teachers guides, special reports and much more.

Showcase of Fine Homes

Search and find your new home in The Daily Review's weekly advertising supplement, Showcase of Fine Homes.

Idol chatter: Sonestown's Aaron Kelly among top 12 finalists on American Idol

On March 11, American Idol revealed the season's Top 12 finalists. Among those finalists was Sonestown, Pa.'s Aaron Kelly, a 16-year-old whose story of a struggling childhood won over the hearts of judges during audition week last summer in Orlando, Fla.


 

Boldness must arise locally to save roads

It's nearly spring and the secondary roads here are in poor shape. Some of the main roads, as well. It's an annual occurrence. But, this year there is a dramatic difference. More roads are in far worse shape than perhaps ever before, in large part becau